First things first; Happy New Year everyone. All of us here at TGA hope you all had a wonderful holiday season and joyous New Year. Sorry for us being so dormant, but things got a little crazy around the holidays and I also have been in the process of starting a new job so that has unfortunately taken precedent over the site for the time being. All that aside we are back and are here to serve up some awards for what we think were the top games of 2011. There are many categories accompanied by many good games so we will not keep you waiting. Here are our 2011 Game of the Year awards, enjoy.
Xbox 360 Exclusive
Nominees
- Gears of War 3
- Forza Motorsport 4
- Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary
Winner: Forza Motorsport 4
Why we picked it:
There we not many 360 exclusives this year and while you would think that would make the decision easier, but alas it really wasn’t. Both Forza and Gears were incredible titles we just felt that Forza 4 was a better game overall. Forza 3 set the bar pretty high when it released in 2009 and the fourth entry exceeded its predecessor in every discernible category and that is why it is our Xbox 360 exclusive game of the year.
PS3 Exclusive
Nominees
- Infamous 2
- Little Big Planet 2
- Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
- Resistance 3
- Disgaea 4: A Promise Unforgotten
- Socom 4
- Yakuza 4
- Killzone 3
Winner: Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
Why we picked it:
While last year was the year of new IPs for Sony’s powerhouse of a machine; this year marked the year of sequels. Once again many great titles to choose from, but no game delivered like Uncharted 3 did. Everything from the story to the jaw dropping graphics and action set pieces set this game part from its fellow PS3 brethren and that is why it was picked as our PS3 exclusive game of the year.
Nintendo Wii Exclusive
Nominees
- Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
- Conduit 2
- Lost in Shadow
- Kirby’s Return to Dreamland
Winner: Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
Why we picked it:
This was a really slow year for the Wii, but even with that being said it had a few exclusives to give the system a proper send off. Not a list of blockbusters, besides the Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword. While not the best Zelda we ever played was a very excellent entry in the Zelda franchise. The game had charm and a great story to draw in newcomers as well as veteran players of the series and that is why we chose it as our Wii exclusive game of the year.
PSP Exclusive
Nominees
- The 3rd Birthday
- Dissidia 012 Final Fantasy
- Patapon 3
- Tactics Ogre: Let us cling Together
Winner: Dissidia 012 Final Fantasy
Why we picked it:
The PSP rode the brakes through most of 2011, but still had a few gems enter its path. Nothing really blew us away on the PSP this year, but the game that we all enjoyed the most was Dissidia 012 Final Fantasy. This FF mash up has depth and creative design in droves and that is why we picked it as our PSP exclusive game of the year.
Nintendo DS Exclusive
Nominees
- Pokemon Black and White
- Solatorobo: Red the Hunter
- Professor Layton: The Last Specter
- Kingdom Hearts Re:coded
Winner: Pokemon Black and White
Why we picked it:
Last year we didn’t pick a Nintendo DS exclusive game of the year, but this year we felt it necessary to make a decision and chose a winner. The Pokemon series might not be respected by all gamers, but here at TGA we hold it in pretty high esteem. While the other nominees were just as worthy of this distinction we ultimately felt that Pokemon Black and White offered the most robust and complete experience this year on the DS and that is why we chose it as our Nintendo DS exclusive game of the year.
Nintendo 3DS Exclusive
Nominees
- Mario Kart 7
- Super Mario 3D Land
- Shinobi
Winner: Super Mario 3D Land
Why we picked it:
2011 marked the first year for the Nintendo 3DS and needless to say things didn’t look good for Nintendo’s latest handheld early on. A major price drop within the first 6 months and not a great lineup of must have games really put a damper on what was supposed to be an exciting time for Nintendo fans. The last couple months of 2011 really turned the system around and in that time frame Super Mario 3D Land was released and was an incredibly engrossing Mario experience. 3DS has some other notable titles but none that we felt captured our attentions like Super Mario 3D Land did and that is why we chose it as our Nintendo 3DS exclusive game of the year.
Best Multiplatform Game of 2011
Nominees
- Batman: Arkham City
- Portal 2
- Skyrim
- Assassin’s Creed Revelations
- Skylanders: Spyro’s Adventure
- Dead Space 2
Winner: Portal 2
Why we picked it:
Multiplatform games are always a tricky beast to tackle when it comes to awards. Such an amazing selection; which is the case most years and it makes it that much harder to grant just one game with the title of being the best. To make a long story short we picked Portal 2 because it was the best experience across all platforms. Skyrim would have taken the title, but certain platforms had issues where as Portal 2 was delivered flawlessly across all and that is why we chose it for our Best Multiplatform game of 2011.
Best Action Game
Nominees
- Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
- Gears of War 3
- Batman: Arkham City
- Driver: San Francisco
Winner: Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
Why we picked it:
Variety was the name of the game when it came to action titles this year, and no matter what your preference there was something of note for everyone. But action comes in many forms, and, for our money, Uncharted 3 best delivered on those varieties, giving the highest grade all-around experience.
Best Adventure Game
Nominees
- L.A. Noire
- Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
- Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
- Skyrim
Winner: Skyrim
Why we picked it:
This was a good time for gamers to be heroes, with a list of truly stellar action titles, both with returning series and some new blood. But, in this humble fanatic’s opinion, nothing in the world can deliver on the promise of a world come to life like the Elder Scrolls series. Becoming the Dragonborn and saving Skyrim is, without exaggeration, the most engrossing thing I’ve ever done, hands down. My hat is off to Bethesda for showing us how it’s done.
Best First Person Shooter
Nominees
- Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3
- Battlefield 3
- Halo: Combat Evolved Anniversary
- RAGE
- Crysis 2
- Deue Ex: Human Revolution
- FEAR 3
- Homefront
- Bulletstorm
Winner: Battlefield 3
Why we picked it:
It seems like every year FPS fans get inundated with more shooters they can handle so they either don’t give everyone a fair shake or they just rest on their laurels and jam on the familiar. This year was no different, but the genre did try some new things that went beyond looking down the sights and clicking the left analog to sprint. Battlefield 3 offered up an experience that might not have deviated too far from the popular FPS formula, but it gave gamers a second popular option to enjoy. Lots of great shooters released this year, but none that pushed the bar as much as Battlefield 3 did and that is why we chose it as our First Person Shooter of the year.
Best Third Person Shooter
Nominees
- Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
- Saints Row: The Third
- Gears of War 3
- Red Faction: Armageddon
- Earth Defense Force: Insect Armageddon
Winner: Saints Row: The Third
Why we picked it:
Saints Row is up against some pretty accomplished competition, but The Third was able to differentiate itself from the crowd because of its overtly facetious nature and just offered up a unique experience within a relatively saturated genre. I was skeptical about SR: The Third originally, but having played it extensively I came to realize that the game is brilliant in its design because it doesn’t follow normal conventions, but better yet it mocks them. SR: The Third is a shining example of what a Third Person Shooter (and sand box) game should entail and that is why we chose it as our Third Person Shooter of the year.
Best Sports Game
Nominees
- NBA 2K12
- FIFA 12
- MLB 11: The Show
- NCAA Football 12
Winner: FIFA 12
Why we picked it:
While none of us here at TGA are huge sports gamers we do recognize that sports games as an important category to acknowledge. I usually get a taste of every sports game that comes out through a myriad of friends and I usually formulate an opinion relatively quickly (under 5 minutes usually). FIFA 12 was a game that I had played and at first it felt a lot like last year’s iteration, but after having spent some serious time with the title I came to the conclusion that is was a much better experience. Every conceivable mechanic was improved and made for a much more interactive and enjoyable simulation. FIFA 12 is not only our pick for the Best Sports game of the year, but may very well be the best sports game I have ever played.
Best Racing Game
Nominees
- Forza Motorsport 4
- Dirt 3
- Mario Kart 7
- Shift 2: Unleashed
- Need For Speed: The Run
- Driver: San Francisco
Winner: Forza Motorsport 4
Why we picked it:
When a racing game gets released, just like a sports game I can form an opinion hastily (but also with better precision, if that makes any sense to you). So when it came time for us to select our favorite racing game it didn’t take very long to decide. Forza Motorsport 4 is the epitome of racing excellence. Like I said earlier this game surpasses and improves upon everything that made its predecessor amazing and nothing else in the genre this year could really hold a candle to it and that is why we chose it our Best Racing game of the year.
Best Puzzle Game
Nominees
- Portal 2
- Catherine
- Professor Layton: The Last Specter
Winner: Portal 2
Why we picked it:
The first Portal changed how gamers envisioned a puzzle game to look, play and feel. The level of dedication to Portal 2 and production values associated with the title were absolutely amazing and exceeded our expectations. Portal 2 performed the same feats as the firs, but also did them exponentially better and that is why we chose it as our Puzzle game of the year.
Best 2D Platformer
Nominees
- Rayman Origins
- Little Big Planet 2
Winner: Rayman Origins
Why we picked it:
Rayman Origins was an absolute treat to play and offered a great escape from the onslaught of other somewhat homogenized games. The games art direction rivals almost anything else that out this year and probably the foreseeable future and that is why we chose it as our 2D Platformer of the year.
Best 3D Platformer
Nominees
- Super Mario 3D Land
- Sonic Generations
- De Blob 2
- Alice: Madness Returns
Winner: Super Mario 3D Land
Why we picked it:
Super Mario 3D Land is a shining example that Mario is still a powerhouse of a platforming franchise and is arguably one of the best reasons to own a Nintendo 3DS. Everything about Super Mario 3D Land was enjoyable and really showcased how 3D needs to be done on Nintendo’s handheld and that is why we chose it for our 3D Platformer of the year (3D in 3D huzzah!!).
Best Survival Horror Game
Nominees
- Dead Island
- Dead Space 2
- Dead Rising 2: Off The Record
Winner: Dead Space 2
Why we picked it:
2011 was a pretty light year for Survival Horror, but what was released really gave fans of the genre something they could be scared of. I originally wanted to select Dead Island, but one thing kept it from beating out Dead Space 2 and that was atmosphere. Don’t get me wrong Dead Island created it and well at certain points, but Dead Space 2 created it and never let you escape it. Dead Space 2 always kept you alert and for those who snoozed got a rude awakening by a necromorph. Dead Space 2 was in your face aggressive through and through and that is why we chose it as our Survival Horror game of the year.
Best Fighting Game
Nominees
- Mortal Kombat
- Marvel vs. Capcom 3
- Ultimate Marvel vs. Capcom 3
- Tekken Hybrid
- The King of Fighters XIII
Winner: Mortal Kombat
Why we picked it:
I feel fighting games define a generation just as much if not more so than most other genres. This year we saw one of the most influential fighting franchises return to its true form and that was Mortal Kombat. This year’s “reboot” of MK floored us here at TGA with how good it was. Blood, guts and other acts of gratuitous violence marked the return of MK and we couldn’t be more satisfied with it. MK performed flawless victories on every other fighting game this year and that is why we chose it as our Fighting game of the year.
Best Music Game
Nominees
- Rocksmith
- Dance Central 2
- Just Dance 3
Winner: Rocksmith
Why we picked it:
As far as we are concerned Music games are a wavering concept that many publishers are straying away from. The music gaming market became so incredibly saturated that people finally just said “screw it” and stop playing them (at least we did). Well Rocksmith was able to pull us out of our music gaming funk and give the genre another chance. Rocksmith isn’t the most revolutionary thing we have ever seen, but it does deserve credit for what it performs well and that is teaching you the guitar interactively and that is why we chose it as our Music game of the year.
Best RPG
Nominees
- Skyrim
- Dark Souls
- Catherine
- Deus Ex: Human Revolution
- Dragon Age 2
- Pokemon Black and White
- Dissidia 012 Final Fantasy
- Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
Winner: Skyrim
Why we picked it:
I don’t want to say it was the obvious choice, but it really was. Nothing that came out this past year even comes close to offering the same amount of content that Skyrim does or will offer in the future with inevitable DLC. Skyrim has a scary amount of things to do and see and will most likely be ruining peoples’ lives well into this year (and possibly next) and that is why we chose it as our RPG of the year.
Best Story of the Year
Nominees
- Resistance 3
- Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
- Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
- Gears of War 3
- Catherine
- Deus Ex: Human Revolution
- Skyrim
Winner: Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
Why we picked it:
This is always one category I dread deliberating on because it is almost as hard as choosing the overall game of the year. The sheer amount of games released this year with amazing stories was completely overwhelming, but when it came down to it we chose Skyward Sword for one particular reason and that was because the story was the most vital component of the game. The story intertwined within Skyward Sword is very engaging, but it is also what really drives you to push forward. Some games you push forward for the next fire fight or a huge boss battle, but with Skyward Sword you really push forward for that next piece of the puzzle and that is why we chose it as our Best Story of the year.
Best Graphics
Nominees
- Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
- Gears of War 3
- Rage
- Skyrim
- Crysis 2
- Battlefield 3
Winner: Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
Why we picked it:
The folks over at Naughty Dog are among some of the most distinguished game designers in the industry and the proof is Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception. Uncharted 3 is a visual masterpiece and nothing that we have seen in recent memory rivals the graphical prowess of UC3 and that is why we chose it for Best Graphics in a game for 2011.
Best Soundtrack in a Game
Nominees
- Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
- Saints Row: The Third
- Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
- Child of Eden
- Patapon 3
Winner: Saints Row: The Third
Why we picked it:
Audio is just as important as visuals because one compliments the other. Many games had great sound work, but Saints Row: The Third had great sound work coupled with a kick ass licensed soundtrack that kept the action fast and the relaxation mellow; so that is why we chose it for the Best Soundtrack in a game.
Best XBLA/PSN Game
Nominees
- Bastion
- Orcs Must Die
- Renegade Ops
- Outland
- Trine 2
- Gatling Gears
Winner: Outland
Why we picked it:
This particular distinction was hard for us to agree on (I was all about Renegade Ops), but after careful analysis we decided that Outland was the best Arcade game to release this year for a few reasons. For one it was both on XBLA and PSN which made it an experience accessible to a wide variety of gamers and secondly the game just kicked ass. We really liked Outland for its art style, combat mechanics and exceptional platforming controls and that is why we chose it as our XBLA/PSN game of the year.
Best Indie Game
Nominees
- VolChaos
- Firing Range
- DLC Quest
- No Pain No Brain
Winner: DLC Quest
Why we picked it:
Indie games usually get swept under the rug and most people regard them as trash. Unfortunately there are an exorbitant amount of really bad Indie Games, but within that ocean of crap lies a few pearls that you should give a try and no other Indie Title we played this year was more indicative of that than DLC Quest. DLC Quest had the makings of an arcade game on a micro level, but it satirical nature was a blast to experience and offered up a brief yet incredibly enjoyable experience and that is why we chose it as our Indie Game of the year.
Best DLC
Nominees
- Gears of War 3: RAAM’s Shadow
- Mass Effect 2: Arrival
- Dead Space 2: Severed
- Infamous: Festival of Blood
- Battlefield 3: Back to Karkand
Winner: Mass Effect 2: Arrival
Why we picked it:
Mass Effect 2 had some truly remarkable pieces of downloadable content and Arrival marked the last piece of content before Mass Effect 3. Arrival was the starting point for the bridging of ME 2 and 3 and the events that transpired in Arrival left us wanting more and that is why we chose it as our Best DLC of the year.
Biggest Disappointment of 2011
Nominees
- Batman: Arkham City
- Brink
- X-Men Destiny
- L.A. Noire
- Spiderman: Edge of Time
- Hunted: The Demon’s Forge
- RAGE
- Duke Nukem: Forever
- Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
- Shadows of the Damned
- Homefront
Winner: Batman: Arkham City
Why we picked it:
This year delivered what seemed to be just an immense amount of huge titles (usually every year, but I digress). The problem with huge titles is that they have huge expectations to live up to and when they fall short we can’t help but feel anything other than disappointed. The list of disappointments this year is quite grand and most of you probably think we are insane for the titles nominated, but we have our reasons. Our biggest disappointment this year by a slim margin was Batman: Arkham City. AC was easily one of our most anticipated titles to release in 2011, but haphazard storytelling and content overload turned what was supposed to be a potential game of the year into just another mediocre sandbox game. AC isn’t a bad game, but it reached for the stars only to be denied by a pack of disappointed nimbus clouds. We had really high hopes for the game and maybe that is why we felt so let down by the experience. So it pains us to say it, but Batman: Arkham City is our Biggest Disappointment of 2011.
Worst Game of 2011
Nominees
- Thor: God of Thunder
- Duke Nukem: Forever
- Mindjack
Winner (or Loser, depends on how you look at it): Thor: God of Thunder
Why we picked it:
A game based on a movie was awful, no way. Holy shit was this game bad. How something this atrocious made its way to store shelves is beyond my comprehension. I use Robocop for Xbox as a barometer of awfulness and Thor makes Robocop seem border line enjoyable. If you have any respect for yourself or just video games in general you should avoid this game completely. Like Thor’s hammer only he should pick this game up and smash it into a million tiny pieces never to be reconstructed. That is why Thor: God of Thunder is our Worst game of the year.
Best Game you Never Heard of in 2011
Nominees
- Solatorobo: Red the Hunter
- Earth Defense Force: Insect Armageddon
- Alice: Madness Returns
Winner: Earth Defense Force: Insect Armageddon
Why we picked it:
EDF: Insect Armageddon is the sequel to another less known title called Earth Defense Force 2017 (which rocks too). EDF: IA flew well under the radar because this year was absolutely ridiculous with releases and blockbuster titles. The game is just a blast to play alone or with friends and it is something that you should check out if you are looking for some mindless fun. The fun factor alone is a great selling point and that is why we chose it as our Best Game you Never Heard of in 2011.
Best Voice Acting in a Game
Nominees
- Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
- Portal 2
- Batman: Arkham City
- Saints Row: The Third
Winner: Portal 2
Why we picked it:
Wheatley, nuff said. We are serious; nothing else needs to be said.
Biggest Surprise of 2011
Nominees
- Bulletstorm
- Skylanders: Spyro’s Adventure
- Driver San Francisco
Winner: Skylanders: Spyro’s Adventure
Why we picked it:
Skylanders was shaping up to be just another gimmicky kids game to fleece parents out of their hard earned money. While the game isn’t completely innocent in that regard it still provided an incredible experience for people of all ages. This game was designed for children, but it also has appeal for teenages and adults as well through humorous dialogue and engaging quests to undertake and that is why we chose it as our Biggest Surprise of 2011.
Overall Game of the Year 2011
Nominees
- Portal 2
- Skyrim
- Dead Space 2
- Gears of War 3
- Uncharted 3: Drake’s Deception
- Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
And the Winner is …
Portal 2
Reader’s Choice for GOTY: Skyrim
Why we picked it:
Portal started off as something that was just plugged into the Orange Box to add value, but it did something far more than that. It took the conventions of puzzle and platform gaming and flipped them upside down and all around and created one of the most special IPs we have seen in the last 10 years.
Portal 2 is the almost perfect realization of what a video game can be. Our second trip to the Aperture Science Facility was beyond our wildest dreams. Everything from the brilliant voice acting to the mind crunching puzzles immersed the player in a world that we wanted to be a part of. I can’t tell you how many of us went through this game time and time again thinking “how could I approach this differently” or just simply replaying a level to laugh at Wheatley’s cunning dialogue. Everything about Portal 2 far exceeded our expectations and we couldn’t have been happier with the final product and that is why we chose it as our Overall Game of the Year for 2011.
Conclusion
This is our second year doing Game of the Year Awards and it is always a blast sitting down deliberating a year’s worth of gaming over a few short weeks then delivering our results to you our blessed readers. We thank you from the bottom of our hearts for your continued support and readership; after all we do this for you, so thanks again and stay tuned for another action filled year from TGA. As always you can follow us on Twitter @GamersAbstract and like us on Facebook for more content.
TGA’s Game of the Year Awards 2011